Ways to Apply for a Mortgage: Pros, Cons, and What’s Best for You

Mortgage expert explaining how to apply for a mortgage and the pros and cons of each option

In short

You can apply for a mortgage in person, online or by phone. Online applications are fast and convenient, but many rely on automated decisions that can decline you over small errors without a loan officer ever reviewing your file, while phone applications add human review. However you apply, verify the lender's NMLS number and licensing before sharing personal information.

If you’re thinking about buying a home, one of the first questions you’ll face is how to apply for a mortgage. Most buyers assume there’s only one option—fill out an online application and hope for the best.

That assumption costs people time, money, and sometimes the house.

After nearly two decades as a mortgage lender, I want to walk you through the different ways to apply for a mortgage, the pros and cons of each, and how to choose the option that actually works best for you.

The Main Ways to Apply for a Mortgage

There are three primary ways to apply for a home loan today:

  1. In-person mortgage application
  2. Online (digital) mortgage application
  3. Mortgage application over the phone

Each has advantages—and serious drawbacks if you don’t understand how lenders use them.

In-Person Mortgage Applications: The Old-School Method

Is Applying for a Mortgage in Person Still Common?

Short answer: No.

While it used to be standard to walk into a bank branch and sit down with a loan officer, in-person mortgage applications are now rare.

Most banks have shifted to:

  • Call centers
  • Online mortgage platforms
  • Centralized processing teams

Even most mortgage brokers no longer meet clients face-to-face.

Pros of an In-Person Mortgage Application

  • Personal interaction
  • Helpful for buyers who need face-to-face reassurance

Cons of an In-Person Mortgage Application

  • Extremely time-inefficient
  • Requires taking time off work
  • Slower processing
  • Limited availability

For most buyers, this option simply doesn’t make sense anymore.

Online Mortgage Applications (Digital Mortgages)

What Is a Digital Mortgage Application?

A digital mortgage application allows you to apply for a home loan online—on your phone, tablet, or computer—anytime, anywhere.

This has become the most common way buyers apply for mortgages.

Pros of Applying for a Mortgage Online

✔ Apply anytime (24/7)
✔ Fast — often completed in 5–10 minutes
✔ Easy document uploads
✔ Fewer spelling and data entry errors
✔ Convenient for busy buyers

From a technology standpoint, digital mortgages are powerful. You can:

  • Upload pay stubs and bank statements
  • Track loan status
  • Receive document requests instantly

Cons of Online Mortgage Applications (This Is Important)

Here’s what most buyers don’t realize:

Many online mortgage systems use automated decision-making.

That means:

  • A computer may auto-decline you
  • No loan officer reviews your application
  • Small errors trigger unnecessary denials

For example:

  • A credit score of 618 instead of 620
  • Incorrect income entry
  • Debt numbers entered wrong

I cannot tell you how many buyers say:

“You’re the only lender who actually called me.”

That’s because computers don’t ask follow-up questions—people do.

Mortgage Applications by Phone: The Best of Both Worlds

Why Phone Mortgage Applications Are Making a Comeback

We brought back phone mortgage applications for one simple reason:

👉 Technology without human review is hurting buyers.

Especially first-time home buyers.

Pros of Applying for a Mortgage Over the Phone

✔ Real loan officer reviews your information
✔ Immediate answers to your questions
✔ No auto-declines without explanation
✔ Faster than you think (often under 10 minutes)
✔ Personalized mortgage strategy

With today’s technology, phone applications are:

  • Quick
  • Secure
  • Far more accurate than self-entered applications

Who Can Take a Mortgage Application by Phone?

Only a licensed loan officer can legally take your application.

That matters.

If someone is:

  • Not licensed in your state
  • Not providing NMLS information
  • Hard to verify online

🚩 That’s a red flag.

How to Verify a Legitimate Mortgage Lender (Critical for SEO + Safety)

Before you apply for a mortgage, online or by phone, verify the lender.

What to Look For:

  • NMLS number listed clearly
  • Licensing information on the website
  • A verifiable phone number
  • Google Business profile
  • Consistent contact information across platforms

Mortgage applications require:

  • Social Security number
  • Date of birth
  • Employment details
  • Bank account information

That’s an identity theft toolkit in the wrong hands.

Digital Mortgage vs Human Review: Why It Matters

A computer can only make a correct decision if the application is filled out perfectly.

Buyers don’t fill out applications like underwriters.

That’s why:

  • Human review matters
  • Follow-up questions matter
  • Strategy matters

A computer might say “no” when the real answer is:

“Not yet—but here’s how we fix it.”

Which Mortgage Application Option Is Best for You?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer.

Choose Based on Your Comfort Level:

  • Want speed and convenience? → Online application
  • Want guidance and answers? → Phone application
  • Want face-to-face interaction? → In-person lender

The most important thing is not how you apply—it’s who reviews it.

Final Thoughts: Don’t Let a Computer Decide Your Future

Buying a home is the biggest purchase most people ever make.

You should not be:

  • Picking loan programs alone
  • Getting declined without explanation
  • Trusting a computer over an expert

Whether you’re ready to buy now, next year, or five years from now, the right lender will help you build a plan—not crush your dream.

Have questions about your situation?

Jen's team helps buyers plan their purchase in all 50 states, whether it's next month or ten years from now.

Filed underMortgage 101