Why More Home Buyers Are Avoiding New Construction
Oct 01, 2025
Over the last few years, I’ve noticed a major shift in buyer behavior.
More and more home buyers are intentionally avoiding new construction and instead searching for homes built in the 1970s, 80s, 90s, and early 2000s. This isn’t nostalgia—it’s a calculated decision based on quality, livability, and long-term satisfaction.
Let’s talk about what’s driving this change.
- Quality Concerns Are Front and Center
Quality is the biggest reason buyers are walking away from new construction.
Years ago, if a builder cut corners, most people never knew. Today? That’s impossible. Between Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Reddit, and review sites, poor-quality builds are exposed immediately—and buyers are paying attention.
I’ve been in mortgage lending for over 18 years, and I can tell you honestly:
I have never seen this many issues with new construction.
From houses sliding off foundations, to improper grading causing flooding, to gas lines not being connected, there are thousands of documented cases online. This isn’t one or two horror stories. It’s a pattern.
Warranty Issues Are Killing Builder Reputations
One of the most common complaints I hear from buyers is that builders don’t honor their warranties.
Builders may think they’re saving money by denying claims, but what they’re actually doing is destroying their reputation. Buyers research builders now. They read reviews. They look up lawsuits. And when they see two-star ratings and endless complaints, they walk—immediately.
Some builders still care deeply about quality. Many do not. And buyers are no longer willing to gamble.
- Material Quality Has Declined Since 2020
To be fair, not all quality issues are the builder’s fault.
Across many industries, material quality has declined over the last several years. I saw this firsthand during a remodel—brand-name windows with seals failing within a year. That wasn’t a contractor issue; it was a manufacturing issue.
Windows, tubs, fixtures, appliances—buyers are noticing that new doesn’t always mean better anymore.
This has made buyers rethink the old assumption that new construction equals peace of mind.
- Builders Aren’t Listening to What Buyers Want
Another major issue? Builders are ignoring consumer trends.
Right now, new construction feels driven by spreadsheets—not people.
The dominant strategy seems to be:
- Buy land
- Pack in as many houses as possible
- Shrink lot sizes
- Maximize price
On paper, that looks profitable. In reality, many of these homes aren’t selling. Builders then offer massive incentives and eat carrying costs, losing money anyway.
Here’s the disconnect:
No buyer dreams of opening their blinds and staring directly into their neighbor’s bathroom.
Yet that’s exactly what many new developments offer—at prices that rival older homes with real space and privacy.
- Smaller Homes Don’t Match Today’s Lifestyle
The average size of new construction homes has dropped to the lowest level in over 15 years.
Meanwhile, buyer needs have expanded.
Since COVID:
- More people work from home
- Homes are expected to function as retreats
- Families want flexibility, not just efficiency
A household that once needed 3–4 bedrooms may now realistically need 4–6:
- Two separate home offices
- Guest space
- Flex rooms for work, school, or hobbies
Buyers are looking at new builds that don’t meet these needs and asking themselves:
Why would I pay more for less?
- Lot Sizes Are Shrinking—And Buyers Want Land
Lot size is another huge factor.
- Over 40% of new builds sit on lots under 7,000 square feet
- Average lot size is around 9,500 square feet
- Only 9% of new constructions offer lots over half an acre
What buyers are asking for:
- A yard
- Space for kids to play
- Room to entertain
- Gardens
- Pools
- Privacy
Many buyers want the option to grow food, entertain friends, or simply feel secure in their space. Tiny lots don’t allow for that and shared parks don’t replace private yards, especially for families working from home.
- Older Homes Are Making a Comeback (For Good Reason)
Because of all this, buyers are shifting toward homes built in the 70s, 80s, and 90s.
These homes often offer:
- Larger lots
- Bigger room sizes
- More flexible layouts
- Better materials in many cases
Yes, older homes may need updates. A roof might need replacement. Systems may be older.
But many buyers are saying:
If I can get land, space, and privacy, I’ll happily replace the roof.
Older does not mean worse. It often means different and sometimes better aligned with today’s needs.
Final Thoughts: New Construction Isn’t Automatically Better
The idea that new construction equals fewer problems, better quality, and happier homeowners is no longer a given.
That doesn’t mean all builders are bad—but it does mean buyers need to:
- Research builders carefully
- Read reviews
- Understand tradeoffs
- Compare new vs. older homes honestly
At the end of the day, my goal isn’t to push you toward new or old, it’s to help you buy a home you’ll actually be happy living in.
And right now, for many buyers, that home isn’t brand new.
Have mortgage questions? Call or text us at 786-933-2077.
Ready to apply? https://zerostressmortgage.com
Book A Time to Chat calendly.com/jennifer-beeston
